|Cancer||Cell death||Cell cycle||Cytoskeleton||Exo/endocytosis||Differentiation||Division||Organelles||Signalling||Stem cells||Trafficking|
Cell Biology International (2006) 30, 747754 (Printed in Great Britain)
Studying cellular architecture in three dimensions with improved resolution: Ta replicas revisited
Pilar Cabezas and Cristina Risco*
Department of Structure of Macromolecules, Centro Nacional de Biotecnología, CSIC, Campus Universidad Autónoma, Darwin 3, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain
Metal replicas have been used for surface analysis of biological structures with a variety of spatial resolutions. Platinum (Pt) has been the metal of choice because it provides very stable replicas and images of high contrast. Some other metals, such as tantalum (Ta) have been reported to provide better resolution on isolated macromolecular complexes and cellular structures. Our goal is to study the gain in detail with Ta and to evaluate if it provides enough detail and resolution to assist in the study of complex volumes of intact cellular structures obtained by methods that reach molecular resolution. To this purpose Pt and Ta replicas of cellular structures and viruses have been studied by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Replicas of Ta show new details on the surface of two types of isolated viral particles such as 100
Keywords: Cell architecture, Freeze-fracture, Freeze-etching, 3D analysis, Ta replicas.
*Corresponding author. Tel.: +34 91 5854507; fax: +34 91 5854506.
Since the introduction of metal replicas for studying the surface of biological structures in combination with transmission electron microcopy, resolution has been limited by a number of factors such as the size of the metal grain overlaid on the structures and the shadowing conditions (Egelman et al., 1989; Ruben and Yurchenco, 1994). Platinum/carbon (Pt/C) has been the metal of choice for many years when visualizing surfaces of cellular structures, because it provides very stable replicas and images of high contrast (Fujimoto and Pinto da Silva, 1988; Risco and Pinto da Silva, 1995; Severs, 1991). The importance of a number of factors in the resolution and quality of metal replicas, such as the shadowing angle, the performance of rotary versus unidirectional shadowing, the outgassing times, or the heating of the specimens during metal deposition has been explored in the past to obtain the highest resolution with Pt replication of macromolecular complexes, either isolated or integrated into more complex biological structures (Costello and Escaig, 1989; Ruben, 1989; Slayter, 1976).
All these studies provided very valuable knowledge that was consequently incorporated as technical improvements in the freeze-fracture/freeze-etching units and protocols. Looking for alternative metals that could provide better resolutions, the mixture of platinum/iridium/carbon (Pt/Ir/C) or tantalum (Ta) have been tested (Bachmann et al., 1985; Peters, 1986; Wepf et al., 1991). Tantalum is a biocompatible inorganic material that has been used to support adequate reconstruction of tissues and functional three-dimensional cell cultures (Kokubo et al., 2004; Poznansky et al., 2000; Rosenzweig et al., 1997). In the structural biology field, tantalum has been used for making replicas of macromolecular complexes. Since Ta forms a thinner layer of fine grain when compared to Platinum, it distorts the true dimensions of particles and structures to a lesser extent. Thus, Ta replicas showed a detectable increase in resolution of individual particles, either isolated or integrated in membranes (Gross et al., 1985; Schnyder et al., 1991; Studer et al., 1981).
Sendai virus nucleocapsids, for example, present different helical states, one of them observed only in Ta preparations (Egelman et al., 1989). Optimal results were also obtained with membrane proteins reconstituted into proteoliposomes. Purified lac permease and cytochrome o oxidase were examined by freeze-fracture EM with Pt/C or Ta replicas (Costello et al., 1987). The intramembrane particle diameters in tantalum replicas were about 20–25% smaller than those observed in conventional platinum/carbon replicas, indicating that the dimensions of the particles revealed with tantalum more accurately reflect the sizes of the lac permease and cytochrome o. One important problem that is particularly difficult to resolve with integral membrane proteins is their state of oligomerization. The dimensions of intramembrane particles (IMPs) observed with tantalum replicas were sufficient to contain monomers of each protein and too small to contain dimers. Careful inspection of these IMPs reveals two major domains of unequal size surrounding a notch or cleft. This type of analysis can be particularly useful to study the structure of macromolecular complexes that have not been susceptible of isolation in homogeneity for subsequent single particle analysis, such as many membrane proteins.
The advantages of tantalum have also been demonstrated using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) (Peters, 1985). Isolated nuclear envelopes were coated with a continuous film of chromium or tantalum. Surface studies may be important in understanding how the NPC (nuclear pore complex) interacts with other structures such as the lamina, chromatin, membranes and cytoplasmic structures and how this interaction is related to function. In addition to the NPC baskets and features of the cytoplasmic face of the NPCs, which have been shown by others, tantalum replicas showed a previously unknown structure, the NEL (nuclear envelope lattice) that appears to be distinct from the nuclear lamina (Goldberg and Allen, 1992). In addition, the nucleoplasmic filaments that make up the baskets were seen attached to the outer periphery of the coaxial ring at a position between each of its subunits. These filaments extend into the nucleoplasm and insert at the distal end to the smaller basket ring (Goldberg and Allen, 1993).
Our main objectives in this work have been exploring the potential of Ta after freeze-fracture and freeze-etching for 3D analysis of viral and cellular structures, and estimating the potential use of these replicas as a support in the interpretation of 3D maps of cells obtained with other techniques that reach a molecular resolution. Viruses are very adequate structural models for these studies since as isolated particles they exhibit a variable level of complexity and inside cells they produce a high number of identical structures, facilitating their detection and study within the very complex intracellular environment.
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Viruses and cells
Bunyamwera virus particles were purified from supernatants of infected BHK-21 cells by centrifugation in Optiprep gradients as described (Novoa et al., 2005a). Vaccinia virus (strain Western Reserve) was propagated in HeLa cells and intracellular mature viruses (IMVs) that were purified in sucrose gradients following well established methods (Esteban, 1984), were kindly provided by Dr. Mariano Esteban (CNB-CSIC, Madrid), as well as control and VV-infected HeLa cells. Cultures of Entamoeba histolytica were supplied by Dr. Rosana Sánchez (Instituto de Biotecnología, UNAM, Cuernavaca, Mexico).
2.2 Freeze-etching of isolated particles
Purified viral particles were adsorbed onto recently exfoliated mica sheets, fast-frozen in liquid ethane and transferred to a BAF 060 freeze-fracture unit (BAL-TEC, Liechtenstein) previously cooled at −150
2.3 Negative staining of isolated particles
Viruses were adsorbed onto EM grids covered by formvar and carbon and made hydrophilic by glow-discharge. Adsorbed viral particles were washed and stained with 2% uranyl acetate using standard procedures (Novoa et al., 2005a).
2.4 Freeze-fracture and surface replication
For conventional freeze-fracture, cell cultures were fixed with aldehydes and cryoprotected with glycerol as described (Risco and Pinto da Silva, 1998; Risco et al., 2002), fast-frozen in liquid ethane and transferred to the BAF 060 unit at a temperature of −150
Infected cells were fast-frozen in liquid ethane and subsequently substituted (at −90
2.6 Image analysis
All samples were studied in a Jeol 1200-EX II electron microscope operating at 80
Viruses and eukaryotic cells were processed by freeze-etching or freeze-fracture before making replicas of Pt or Ta. We have studied two enveloped viruses of different sizes and structural complexity (Fig. 1): Bunyamwera virus (BUNV), a Bunyavirus of approximately 100
Visualizing isolated large macromolecular complexes: the surface of isolated viruses. Bunyamwera virus (A–C) and vaccinia virus (VV) (D and E) as visualized by freeze-etching and metal replication with Pt/C or Ta/W, as indicated. F and G show isolated Bunyamwera virus (F) and VV (G) as visualized by negative staining. Arrow in F points to the thick envelope of Bunyamwera virus while arrows in G point to deformed envelope parts that collapsed during drying of the particle. Bars: 100
These globular particles, of an approximate diameter of 9
To make a comparison with a simple, widespread method for studying isolated particles, viruses were also visualized by negative staining (Fig. 1F,G). This method provided a different type of information such as the visualization of a rather thick envelope in Bunyamwera virus particles (Fig. 1F) or the soft, deformable nature of VV envelope (Fig. 1G). However, fine, well-preserved details on the surface of viruses were appreciated only in Ta replicas. The reason for this is that although negative staining is a very useful method that provides medium resolution when dealing with non-enveloped viruses and macromolecular complexes, it can be too disrupting for non-fixed membranous structures, such as viral envelopes (Dubochet et al., 1994; Harris and Scheffler, 2002; Kiselev et al., 1990).
Looking for large macromolecular assemblies inside cells, we have visualized viruses within the intracellular environment. We have studied the areas of assembly of vaccinia virus in infected HeLa cells (Fig. 2), in particular the perinuclear regions where viral factories and spherical immature viruses (IVs) assemble (Novoa et al., 2005b). The typical aspect of these areas with spherical immature viruses, as seen in two dimensions, is shown in thin sections of cells processed by freeze-substitution (inset on top of Fig. 2A). Pt replicas of these regions show rather flat areas (asterisks) where fractured IVs exhibit a rough texture in cross-fractured particles, as well as in concave and convex views of IVs (white stars in Fig. 2A).
Visualizing large viruses inside cells: structures in the cytoplasm of VV-infected eukaryotic HeLa cells. Immature spherical VV particles (white stars) in the cytoplasmic areas of assembly, as visualized by freeze-fracture and metal replication with Pt/C or Ta/W (A and B, respectively). Inset on top of A shows an equivalent area of an infected cell processed by freeze-substitution (FS) and thin sectioning. Asterisks mark representative areas of the cytoplasm. Arrows in B point to linear arrays of particles in the direction of the alignment, a feature that is only distinguished in Ta/W replicas. Insets on the bottom show characteristic spherical viral particles. (C) Stereo-pair of the area shown in (B) and rotated 90° counterclockwise. Bars: 200
Ta replicas show that IVs are formed by linear elements, observed in all views (arrows in Fig. 2B). Their width, around 30
Looking for smaller macromolecular-containing structures inside cells, we have studied the nuclear envelope (Fig. 3). There are 3D maps of medium resolution of nuclear pores recently obtained by electron tomography (Beck et al., 2004). After freeze-fracture and Pt replication, the nuclear envelope of E. histolytica cells shows a regular distribution of nuclear pores on a rather flat sheet (Fig. 3A). Nuclear pores have particles with no defined pattern (Fig. 3A, inset). When these cells are replicated with Ta, the pores have a well-defined ring inserted in a cavity (Fig. 3B). The particles of the ring and the surrounding areas are more patent (inset in Fig. 3B). In both types of replicas we show images generated when the fracture plane goes along the outer membrane of the envelope. Nuclear pores with or without a central mass are not clearly distinguished in Pt replicas (Fig. 3A). However, Ta replicas clearly show the presence of an additional mass in different locations within the central area of the pores or on their periphery (arrows in Fig. 3B) while some pores are clearly devoid of this additional mass (arrowheads in Fig. 3B). A mass of variable size, shape and position, known as the central plug/transporter (CP/T), has been recently visualized by electron tomography, and its analysis supports the notion that it makes up, at least in part, cargo complexes arrested during translocation (Beck et al., 2004).
Details of cellular macromolecular complexes in situ: nuclear pores within the nuclear envelope of Entamoeba histolytica cells visualized by freeze-fracture and metal replication with Pt/C or Ta/W, as indicated. Nuclear pores with or without a central mass (arrows and arrowheads, respectively) are distinguished in Ta/W replicas. Bars: 250
A direct demonstration of the increase in detail of large cellular regions with Ta replicas is shown in Fig. 4. Regions of the plasma membrane of E. histolytica cells are here visualized after freeze-fracture and replication with Pt (Fig. 4A) or Ta (Fig. 4B). In addition to individual particles randomly distributed and representing integral membrane proteins, as documented in the literature (Verkleij and Ververgaert, 1978), Pt replicas show some linear structures of unknown nature (Fig. 4A, arrows). Ta replicas reveal that these straight elements are in fact composed of individual particles that exhibit a linear arrangement in the bilayer (Fig. 4B, arrows). Thus, the rod-like structures seen in Pt replicas are in fact “decoration artifacts” (Peters, 1979). In this sense, we have recently demonstrated by immunogold detection and label-fracture techniques that certain receptors have a propensity to form linear arrays in the plasma membrane (Schamel et al., 2005). A variety of diameters are observed for the particles visualized in the plasma membrane replicated with Ta, some of them apparently below 5
Intramembrane particles (IMPs) in plasma membrane. Entamoeba histolytica cells were processed by freeze-fracture and metal replication with Pt/C or Ta/W, as indicated. Arrows in (A) point to linear, stick-like elements of the membrane that in fact correspond to individual particles with a linear arrangement, as visualized in replicas of Ta/W (arrows in B). Bars: 100
The development of methods for the three-dimensional characterization of cells with molecular resolution is nowadays a real breakthrough in structural biology since it offers multiple possibilities and applications (Lučić et al., 2005). In this field, electron microscopy methods are showing new achievements every day. The transition from single particle analysis, a method that requires the computational combination of identical particles (either macromolecular complexes or viruses) to the structural characterization of unique, non-symmetrical objects (such as cells and their parts) is being made possible through the development of approaches such as electron tomography. This is providing 3D maps of organelles and whole cells with unprecedented detail (He et al., 2003; Kürner et al., 2005; Marsh et al., 2000; McIntosh et al., 2005; Messaoudi et al., 2006; Murk et al., 2003; Soto et al., 1994; Steven and Aebi, 2003). Interpretation of tomograms is, however, a complex task and new image processing methods are now being developed (Bajaj et al., 2003; Fernández and Li, 2003; Subramaniam and Milne, 2004). Understanding the very complex tomograms originating from interesting areas of eukaryotic cells will be a considerable challenge, in particular with vitreous sections (Leis et al., 2005). In this sense, the assistance of methods that provide more familiar 3D images with an adequate resolution can be of considerable help.
Freeze-fracture and related techniques have considerably helped to understand the organization of biological membranes (Pinto da Silva and Branton, 1970; Pinto da Silva, 1987). Metal replication has considerably helped to characterize many biological structures in three dimensions (Cetonze et al., 1986; Fujimoto and Pinto da Silva, 1988). Technical developments and knowledge accumulated in this field over the years allow the fabrication of high quality replicas following standard procedures, with improved molecular resolutions for complex cellular structures. The fact that Ta provides higher resolution when visualizing macromolecular complexes and cellular structures, as shown in the present study, is not a new concept. However, we believe that our images provide an intuitive idea of the usefulness and new applications that these methods can have today in the field of 3D EM. In fact new data such as the small masses visualized in the pore complexes, the surface covered by small particles in vaccinia mature virus and the organization of vaccinia immature virus as linear attached pieces, are new details visualized in the images presented in this study. Replicas can also be easily combined with cytochemical techniques for a specific detection of components (Pavan et al., 1990; Pinto da Silva et al., 1981; Robenek et al., 2005; Visco et al., 2000). This detection can be of considerable help for localizing functions in complex 3D maps. Technical advances in EM cytochemistry will also be important in this field (Bendayan, 2000; Mayer and Bendayan, 2001).
In terms of detail, our results suggest that we can be visualizing rather small individual monomers in macromolecular aggregates integrated in cellular structures with a resolution close to the results recently obtained by electron tomography of cellular organelles and large viruses (Baumeister, 2005; Grünewald et al., 2003). With the limitations coming from the fact that we are not visualizing the structures themselves but a replica and the final size is modified, we can estimate that with Ta replicas of the surface of complex structures we are reaching resolutions similar to the values calculated for electron tomograms of cell parts. In fact, the surface of VV mature virus in Ta replicas shows small structures that were not solved by electron tomography of vitrified virus (Cyrklaff et al., 2005). When dealing with whole cells we believe that in combination with high-preservation methods for large structures, such as high pressure freezing (Muller-Reichert et al., 2003; Studer et al., 2001; Walther, 2003), stereo-pairs of Ta replicated surfaces can provide complementary information. This can help us in the process of segmentation, particularly through the assignment of dimensions to certain cell parts and macromolecular assemblies in 3D, when analyzing the very complex tomograms of eukaryotic cells.
We are very grateful to Dr. Rosana Sánchez (Instituto de Biotecnología, UNAM, Cuernavaca, Mexico) and Dr. Mariano Esteban (CNB, Madrid) for providing some of the samples used in this study. This work has been supported by grants 07B/0039/2002 and GR/SAL/0671/2004 from the Comunidad de Madrid and BMC2003-01630 from the Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia of Spain (to C.R.).
Baumeister W. A voyage to the inner space of cells. Prot Sci 2005:14:257-69
Beck M, Förster, F, Ecke, M, Plitzko, JM, Melchior, F, Gerish, G. Nuclear pore complex structure and dynamics revealed by cryoelectron tomography. Science 2004:306:1387-90
Cetonze VE, Ruben, GC, Sloboda, RD. Structure and composition of the cytoskeleton of nucleated erythrocytes: III. Organization of the cytoskeleton of Bufo marinus erythrocytes as revealed by freeze-dried platinum–carbon replicas and immunofluorescence microscopy. Cell Motil Cytoskeleton 1986:6:376-88
Costello MJ, Escaig, J, Matsushita, K, Vitanen, PV, Menick, DR, Kaback, HR. Purified lac permease and cytochrome o oxidase are functional as monomers. J Biol Chem 1987:262:17072-82
Cyrklaff M, Risco, C, Fernández, JJ, Jiménez, MV, Esteban, M, Baumeister, W. Cryo-electro tomography of isolated vaccinia virus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2005:102:2772-7
Goldberg MW, Allen, TD. High resolution scanning electron microscopy of the nuclear envelope: demonstration of a new, regular, fibrous lattice attached to the baskets of the nucleoplasmic face of the nuclear pores. J Cell Biol 1992:119:1429-40
Goldberg MW, Allen, TD. The nuclear pore complex: three-dimensional surface structure revealed by field emission, in-lens scanning electron microscopy, with underlying structure uncovered by proteolysis. J Cell Sci 1993:106:261-74
Griffiths G, Wepf, R, Wendt, T, Locker, JK, Cyrklaff, M, Ross, N. Structure and assembly of intracellular mature vaccinia virus: isolated particle analysis. J Virol 2001:75:1034-55
Grünewald K, Desai, P, Winkler, DC, Heymann, JB, Belnap, D, Baumeister, W. Three-dimensional structure of Herpes Simplex Virus from cryo-electron tomography. Science 2003:302:1396-8
Harris JR, Scheffler, D. Routine preparation of air-dried negatively stained and unstained specimens on holey carbon support films: a review of applications. Micron 2002:33:461-80
Leis A, Andrees, L, Gruska, M, Al-Amoudi, A, Sartori, A, Dubochet, J. Cryo-electron tomography and fluorescence microscopy of unicellular algae in vitreous cryosections. Microsc Microanal 2005:11:Suppl. 2:330CD
Marsh MJ, Mastronarde, DN, Buttle, KF, Howell, KE, McIntosh, JR. Organellar relationship in the Golgi region of the pancreatic beta cell line, HIT-T15, visualized by high resolution electron tomography. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2000:98:2399-406
Messaoudi C, Garreau de Loubresse, N, Boudier, T, Dupuis-Williams, P, Marco, S. Multiple-axis tomography: applications to basal bodies from Paramecium tetraurelia. Biol Cell 2006:98:7:415-25
Murk JLAN, Humbel, BM, Ziese, U, Griffith, JM, Posthuma, G, Slot, JW. Endosomal compartmentalization in three dimensions: implications for membrane fusion. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2003:100:13332-7
Novoa RR, Calderita, G, Cabezas, P, Elliott, RM, Risco, C. Key Golgi factors for structural and functional maturation of Bunyamwera virus. J Virol 2005:79:10852-63
Novoa RR, Calderita, G, Arranz, R, Fontana, J, Granzow, H, Risco, C. Virus factories: associations of cell organelles for viral replication and morphogenesis. Biol Cell 2005:97:147-72
Pavan A, Mancini, P, Lucania, G, Frati, L, Torrisi, MR, Pinto da Silva, P. High-resolution surface views of human lymphocytes during camping of CD4 and HLA antigens as revealed by immunogold fracture-flip. J Cell Sci 1990:96:151-7
Peters KR. Scanning electron microscopy at macromolecular resolution in low energy mode on biological specimens coated with ultra thin metal films. Scanning Electron Microsc 1979:2:133-48
Peters KR. Working at higher magnifications in scanning electron microscopy with secondary and backscattered electrons on metal coated biological specimens and imaging macromolecular cell membrane structures. Scanning Electron Microsc 1985:4:1519-44
Pinto da Silva P. Topology, dynamics, and molecular cytochemistry of integral membrane proteins: a freeze-fracture view. Electron microscopy of proteins 1987:2-38
Pinto da Silva P, Torrisi, MR, Kachar, B. Freeze-fracture cytochemistry: localization of wheat-germ agglutinin and concanavalin A binding sites on freeze-fractured pancreatic cells. J Cell Biol 1981:91:361-72
Poznansky MC, Evans, RH, Foxall, RB, Olszak, IT, Piascik, AH, Hartman, KE. Efficient generation of human T cells from a tissue-engineered thymic organoid. Nat Biotech 2000:18:729-34
Risco C, Pinto da Silva, P. Binding of bacterial endotoxins to the macrophage surface: visualization by fracture-flip and immunocytochemistry. J Histochem Cytochem 1993:41:601-8
Risco C, Pinto da Silva, P. Cellular functions during activation and damage by pathogens: immunogold studies of the interaction of bacterial endotoxins with target cells. Microsc Res Tech 1995:31:141-58
Risco C, Romero, C, Bosch, MA, Pinto da Silva, P. Type II pneumocytes revisited: intracellular membranous systems, surface characteristics, and lamellar body secretion. Lab Invest 1994:70:407-17
Risco C, Rodríguez, JR, López-Iglesias, C, Carrascosa, JL, Esteban, M, Rodríguez, D. Endoplasmic reticulum–Golgi intermediate compartment membranes and vimentin filaments participate in vaccinia virus assembly. J Virol 2002:76:1839-55
Robenek H, Robenek, MJ, Buers, I, Lorkowski, S, Hofnagel, O, Troyer, D. Lipid droplets gain PAT family proteins by interactions with specialized plasma membrane domains. J Biol Chem 2005:280:26330-8
Rosenzweig M, Pykett, M, Marks, DF, Johnson, RP. Enhanced maintenance and retroviral transduction of primitive hematopoietic progenitor cells using a novel three-dimensional system. Gene Ther 1997:4:928-36
Ruben GC. Ultrathin (1
Salanueva IJ, Novoa, RR, Cabezas, P, López-Iglesias, C, Carrascosa, JL, Elliott, RM. Polymorphism and structural maturation of Bunyamwera virus in Golgi and post-Golgi compartments. J Virol 2003:77:1368-81
Schamel WWA, Arechaga, I, Risueño, RM, van Santen, HM, Cabezas, P, Risco, C. Coexistence of multivalent and monovalent TCRs explains high sensitivity and wide range of response. J Exp Med 2005:202:493-503
Schnyder T, Gross, H, Winkler, H, Eppenberger, HM, Wallimann, T. Structure of the mitochondrial creatine kinase octamer: high-resolution shadowing and image averaging of single molecules and formation of linear filaments under specific staining conditions. J Cell Biol 1991:112:95-101
Soto GE, Young, SJ, Martone, ME, Deerinck, TJ, Lamont, S, Carragher, BO. Serial section electron tomography: a method for three-dimensional reconstruction of large structures. Neuroimage 1994:1:230-43
Studer D, Moor, H, Gross, H. Single bacteriorhodopsin molecules revealed on both surfaces of freeze-dried and heavy metal-decorated purple membranes. J Cell Biol 1981:90:153-9
Visco V, Lucania, G, Sansolini, T, Dolo, V, Garofalo, T, Sorice, M. Expression of GM3 microdomains on the surfaces of murine fibroblasts correlates with inhibition of cell proliferation. Histochem Cell Biol 2000:113:43-50
Wepf R, Amrein, M, Bürkliand, U, Gross, H. Platinum/iridium/carbon: a high resolution shadowing material for TEM, STM, and SEM of biological macromolecular structures. J Microsc 1991:163:51-64
Received 21 March 2006/4 April 2006; accepted 11 May 2006doi:10.1016/j.cellbi.2006.05.006